National Security Broadly Conceived: Some Thoughts on The 2026 Northeastern Political Science Convention's Pi Sigma Alpha Lecture

... the task is on us to consider how we can engage national security broadly conceived. Ironically enough, some of the principles at play resemble abolitionist thinking.

National Security Broadly Conceived: Some Thoughts on The 2026 Northeastern Political Science Convention's Pi Sigma Alpha Lecture

At NPSA 2026 The Honorable Alexander Laskaris, former Ambassador to Chad, spoke about the need for political scientists to be more involved with national security. His remarks required a certain courage, because his position faces two major challenges. First, the national security establishment has not always been open to diplomacy, let alone scholarship, for a number of years. There's a very ugly attitude at a number of levels of society and government which holds that anything remotely alien should be neglected or destroyed, not engaged or studied. Second, scholars themselves are skeptical of government. Why shouldn't they be? Assaults on what one can say, teach, and research within academia are commonplace across the United States. It is easy for politicians and bureaucrats who want cheap popularity to attack teachers and academics.

I did respect his bravery and tact in speaking to us, a crowd of political scientists with varied interests. Some are interested in IR and political economy; others want to know how the media influences us; still others compare cases across different countries; the various institutions and mechanisms of American politics are always being debated. I myself do theory and I hope I am asking the question of whether we need any of this (gestures at everything). It is very easy, when you think you know something, to reach positions slightly different from the mainstream.

The former ambassador was clear enough. Researchers of various sorts worked with the federal government to directly help populations in Africa, creating goodwill for the United States and preventing radicalism. Of course, that program–the Minerva Research Initiative--was cut, lambasted by the current administration as a waste of money. But there are a million potential points of interaction between national security broadly conceived and academic work generally. The United States commands (one might even say hoards) considerable resources. Simply sending out academics to teach in locales that want to know different things or sponsoring collaborations between scholars of various countries goes a long way. People want to work together across borders. Why not fund this and win friends? Even in war, you don't "win" by simply destroying what you think is the enemy–that's mindless slaughter, an approach to reality resembling a bad video game. You win by making friends and making the cost of attacking you high. You break an enemy's will to fight by being able to defend yourself in various ways. In addition to this, you try to make peace an attractive option, always remembering that peace is had between former combatants.

And so I think the task is on us to consider how we can engage national security broadly conceived. Ironically enough, some of the principles at play resemble abolitionist thinking. It isn't armed officers with a quick response time who generate the security we need in our neighborhoods; poverty and crime strongly correlate. End poverty and you go a long way to eliminating crime. A question for diplomats and academics going forward is how we can share resources to benefit all. People turn to extremism when they're furious and desperate: launching drones and bombs always creates future enemies.

My own meager thought is that the overall level of knowledge in the U.S. is inadequate and this is not the fault of political science programs. If anything, those programs are being badly neglected in favor of specific technical specializations. A more traditional approach to civics has become cliche, if not parody, because it cannot address whether people's most basic rights are being respected or if government has the capacities it needs to deal with anything. We are often debating whether clean water is owed to residents of the U.S. or if emergency aid should be given to victims of disasters. Those are not arguments we should have; even having them destroys the legitimacy of government while decreasing trust in one's fellow citizens and leaders. Who wants to live near someone who wants to argue out loud that clean water is a luxury? I'd rather not know someone like that exists, but nowadays I have to deal with the fact they vote.

We need more opportunities for teaching the basics of government and the condition of the country. Those opportunities require that the material is treated with respect. It can't be a free-for-all like cable news or talk radio: those rants and debates are worse than demagoguery because they aim to create addicts. The goal is to get people angry or fearful and then keep feeding the outrage. Arguing for little or no government intervention (other than violence) is unfortunate, as it creates feelings of helplessness in a country initiated by "We the People."

The good news is that we can do this at a local level and make it entertaining and useful. Activist groups do things like this often. No reason why we can't just have more lectures featuring, I dunno, people who know things and make the effort to get others to them. At NPSA there were undergraduate research panels. It was an absolute joy to watch the parents and peers of those undergrads not just take pride in their children doing research but see for themselves the investment professors were making in them. What took me aback–what felt like a world I didn't know existed–was how valuable trying to know better was. Everyone was looking for the best question they could ask, wrong answers were seen as serious, credible attempts, and you knew the work of democracy was happening. The older I get, the more I realize there is no substitution for motivation. Including the motivation to work with systems you might have some skepticism towards.